Background

To determine the proportion and reproducibility of cat-allergic mild asthmatics with early asthmatic response (EAR) during cat allergen exposure in a naturalistic exposure chamber (NEC).

Methods

This was a prospective, observational study in 30 cat-allergic mild asthmatics who received two 180-minute cat-allergen (Felis domesticus allergen 1 [Fel d 1]) challenges 27 days apart in an NEC.

Results

An EAR (≥20% reduction from baseline in forced expiratory volume in 1 second [FEV1]) was observed in 67% and 52% of subjects at first and second NEC exposure, respectively, with similar median time to EAR; 44% of subjects had an EAR on Days 1 and 28. Late asthmatic response (≥15% reduction in FEV1 within 24 hours of NEC exit) was observed in 33% of subjects following either exposure. Average FEV1 and total nasal symptom score during NEC exposure were highly correlated within subjects between NEC exposures (r=0.91, p < .0001; r=0.73, p < .001), but total ocular symptom score was not. Time to EAR, but not average FEV1, was significantly associated with NEC Fel d 1 concentration, which was variable. There were no serious adverse events; 12/30 subjects experienced 20 adverse events (including asthma, 10%; headache, 10%).

Conclusions

The NEC model demonstrates that average FEV1 change is highly reproducible and has a low correlation with cat allergen levels. However, time to EAR and incidence of EAR is less reproducible and is highly correlated with NEC allergen levels. Average FEV1, rather than incidence of EAR or time to EAR, could be considered as an endpoint for interventional trials testing cat specific anti-allergy therapies using an NEC.