Platelet-rich preparations, including platelet-rich plasma (PRP), plasma rich in growth factors (PRGF-Endoret®, BTI Biotechnology Institute, Vitoria, Spain), and other blood-derived preparations, have become a focal point in the current research and clinical practice in dermatology due to their regenerative and reparative properties. These biologically active autologous substances are rich in growth factors, cytokines, and proteins that are pivotal in the processes of healing, tissue repair, and regeneration.1 Therefore, these hemoderivatives are increasingly used for a variety of dermatological conditions, including chronic wounds, scars, skin aging, hair loss, and treatment of other aesthetic conditions.2–4, However, platelet-rich formulations differ in their structure, composition, growth factors concentrations, and cytokine profile, which critically affects their biological effects.5 In many cases, variations in therapeutic efficacy could also be attributed to the lack of standardized and reproducible preparation protocols.6
In dermatology, platelet concentrates have demonstrated efficacy in promoting wound healing, reducing scarring, and improving skin rejuvenation.3 Chronic wounds, including diabetic ulcers and pressure ulcers, are challenging to manage and often require advanced therapies.7 Epithelial tissue regeneration is regulated by cellular metabolic pathways. In diabetes, sustained hyperglycemia induces a significant metabolic dysregulation in epithelial cells, thereby compromising their proliferative and reparative capacity and contributing to impaired wound healing. Growth factors are essential for the activation of epithelial stem and progenitor cells, modulating cellular metabolism and promoting cell proliferation, migration, and tissue repair8. Considering the multifaceted cellular and molecular interactions that characterize diabetic wounds, multifunctional hydrogel-based strategies, combining antimicrobial, antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, and blood glucose modulating effects, are increasingly being prioritized as a promising approach for effective therapeutic intervention.9–11
Platelet concentrates have shown to accelerate wound closure by promoting epithelialization and collagen synthesis.12–15 Furthermore, studies have revealed that platelet concentrates can significantly reduce the formation of hypertrophic scars, making them a valuable treatment modality for patients undergoing reconstructive surgery.16 In the context of aesthetic dermatology, platelet concentrates have gained popularity for their role in combating the effects of skin aging.17–19 In this sense, PRGF-Endoret® and other platelet concentrates are frequently used in facial rejuvenation treatments, where they stimulate the production of collagen,20 improving skin tone, texture, and elasticity.21–23 A growing body of scientific evidence suggests that platelet concentrates can stimulate the proliferation of dermal papilla cells and enhance the vascularization of perifollicular tissue, while also accelerating the transition from telogen to anagen, thereby promoting hair follicle regeneration and minimizing hair loss.24
Optimization of Platelet ConcentratesAs previously discussed, platelet concentrates offer numerous advantages and considerable therapeutic potential, but also some specific challenges including a relatively fast release of growth factors and cytokines.25 In order to overcome these limitations, different technologies and manufacturing processes have been developed so far. Many have contributed to significantly enhance the properties of platelet concentrates and their effectiveness for specific uses without introducing exogenous biomaterial or bioactive substances. Indeed, determining precisely the composition of platelet-rich preparations regarding the optimal platelet concentration and the role of leukocytes might be key for their therapeutic efficacy and safety. Many studies with PRGF-Endoret® have reported that a platelet enrichment factor of 2–3 and the absence of leukocytes have resulted in the best outcomes regarding the safety and performance.26–31
As a result, the versatility of plasma rich in growth factors (PRG-Endoret®) has culminated in the development of a wide range of formulations with diverging mechanical and biological characteristics, which are applicable in diverse therapeutic scenarios.29Figure 1 represents the main differences in preparation methods and the resulting formulations that can be manufactured via PRGF-Endoret® protocol, providing a representative example based on a standardized PRP technique. Liquid platelet-rich formulations, including non-activated PRGF-Endoret®, activated PRGF-Endoret®, and PRGF-Endoret®-released supernatants, are commonly injected or topically applied as eyedrops to provide an immediate supply of a large amount cytokines, growth factors, and other bioactive proteins to damaged tissues.30,32–34 On the other hand, PRGF-Endoret®-derived clots constitute disease-specific bioformulations tailored to the pathoanatomic context underlying the damaged tissue that promote a sustained release of cytokines and growth factors usually prepared via fibrin crosslinking with calcium, thrombin, or collagen.30,35 Their viscoelastic properties and biodegradability rates could be also modified by mechanical and/or thermal procedures.36,37
Figure 1 Technical procedures for preparation and administration of PRGF-Endoret® for the treatment of skin pathologies.
Plasma gels are also prepared through thermal treatments, where the thermal dose and time-temperature factors play a crucial role in defining the physical and biological characteristics of the resulting hydrogels.38 Moreover, the mechanical and regenerative properties of the final product can be modified by mixing different proportions of these heat-coagulated albumin gels with other platelet gels or liquid platelet derivatives to address specific therapeutic contexts.23,36,39 These formulations can be used as soft and hard tissue fillers,21,38,39 topical agents,37 and dressings40 or injection administered prior to clot formation.37 The identification of optimized centrifugation conditions and the inclusion of additional filtration steps may be used either to enrich the resulting platelet derivatives in selected components or to exclude other blood constituents, thus modifying fibrin architecture and enhancing their regenerative potential,41 minimizing their immunogenicity,42 modulating their biodegradability,43 or improving their optical properties.44 In addition, thermal treatments have been developed to further reduce the content of soluble components of the immune system (including the complement system and immunoglobulins) in platelet derivatives from patients with systemic immune-mediated disorders.42,45 Platelet-derived extracellular vesicles are nanoparticles derived from activated platelets that contain growth factors, procoagulants, anti-inflammatory factors, pro-angiogenic factors, nucleic acids (mRNA and miRNA), and mitochondria. The most recent advances conducted to isolate these membrane vesicles with essential roles in homeostasis, osteogenesis, angiogenesis, and tissue regeneration from platelet concentrates involve sequential centrifugation steps at increasing G forces over progressively extended centrifugation intervals.43 This technological and scientific development has enabled platelet concentration systems suppliers to provide clinicians with an array of medical products, in accordance with European Parliament and Council Directive 2017/745/EC regarding medical devices.46
From a regulatory perspective, PRP is classified as a medicinal product and is subject to strict regulation within the European Union.47,48 The regulatory framework for platelet derivatives is designed to ensure the quality and safety of blood products throughout their preparation, storage, and distribution (European Parliament and Council Directives 2002/98/EC, 2004/33/EC, 2005/62/EC, 2016/1214).49–52 The core regulation is Directive 2002/98/EC, which governs the quality and safety of blood,49 while Directive 2005/62/EC as regards Community standards and specifications relating to a quality system for blood establishments and its amendment,51 Directive 2016/1214, outline the quality system standards for blood establishments.52 These directives require strict controls on various practices, including blood collection, testing, licensing, qualified personnel, and product traceability. Nevertheless, the implementation of these regulations varies across EU member states, leading to some inconsistencies. This lack of uniformity may prompt EU legislators to step in and standardize the regulatory approach for blood-derived products.53 In Spain, the Agency of Medicines and Medical Devices (AEMPS) included PRP as a non-industrially produced medicinal product (Report/V1/23052013).54 Consequently, PRP therapy must be prescribed exclusively by healthcare professionals – doctors, dentists, or podiatrists – within their specific clinical competencies, and not by any other healthcare or non-healthcare professional. Furthermore, prescribing PRP is restricted to professionals with the relevant expertise and qualifications. Moreover, the treatment must be performed using the proper equipment and instruments that are approved for that purpose by regulatory authorities, and PRP may only be utilized in authorized healthcare facilities that adhere to applicable regional government regulations.
Novel Multifunctional Combined TherapiesLeveraging the regenerative potential of PRP to improve biomaterial safety and performance—alongside achieving controlled delivery of platelet-derived morphogens, proteins, and growth factors—has contributed to the development of advanced combined tissue-regeneration strategies.55 Therefore, therapies that combine tissue-regeneration strategies using platelet derivatives and biomaterials are considered as promising approaches to enhance the stability and durability of platelet-derived therapeutic agents and improve the outcomes of dermatological treatments. In this context, biomaterials, such as composite scaffolds, hydrogels, and synthetic matrices, provide stable mechanical support for the targeted delivery of platelet concentrates, which enable the sustained release of bioactive molecules and protect them from degradation.56 Furthermore, to enhance the biological effect of platelet derivatives with additional antioxidant, antibacterial, and other biological properties, combining these autologous products with different active ingredients or their mixtures may produce a synergistic action, thus improving the therapeutic impact of the combined therapy.57,58
This narrative review aims to consolidate current research on the use of platelet derivatives in combination with other biomaterials, therapeutic agents, or active substances administered simultaneously, regardless of the method of administration, for the treatment of dermatological diseases or aesthetic conditions. By examining the in vitro and in vivo biological effects of different biopolymers and other active substances, the paper summarizes different implementation strategies and evaluates their effectiveness in diverse contexts. Additionally, it highlights deficiencies in the current literature and outlines directions for future research to deepen our understanding of how combining platelet derivatives with other biomaterials and active substances can be used to support and improve skin repair and regeneration.
MethodsA systematic literature search was conducted to identify studies on the use of combination therapy of hemoderivatives and other exogenous elements, molecules, or mixtures (with no restriction regarding their physical state, chemical composition, or biological function) in the treatment of dermatological diseases and aesthetic conditions (including wound/ulcer, burn and scar management, volume restoration, skin ageing, dermatological autoimmune diseases, hair loss, and other conditions affecting the skin). Studies in which platelet derivatives are used as adjuvant therapy for skin reconstruction, tissue regeneration, or soft tissue augmentation surgery based on living tissues, including skin flaps or split thickness skin grafts (STSG) – vascularized or semi-vascularized flaps comprising skin and subcutaneous tissue, mobilized from a donor region to a recipient site during reconstructive or reparative procedures – fat grafts, stromal vascular fraction (SVF), or stem cells were excluded. Only studies in which both agents were administered simultaneously were included, including platelet derivative-loaded hydrogel composites or fibrin-based hydrogels, liquid mixtures of platelet-derivatives and other active substances or topical formulations composed of platelet derivatives, and other biomaterials or therapeutic agents regardless of the method of administration. Accordingly, experimental designs combining hemoderivatives with other therapeutic agents administered separately, including different administration routes or dosing times, were also excluded. The search, with no limitations to language, date or publication status, was carried out using PubMed, Scopus, and Google Scholar databases.
ResultsAfter screening and removing duplicates, the reference list of the preliminary selection was checked to identify additional relevant publications. The details of the literature search and data extraction are provided in a flow diagram (Figure 2). As listed in Table 1, a total of 91 publications reporting in vitro, in vivo, or clinical investigations with the primary or secondary objectives of evaluating the biological effects and/or therapeutic efficacy of different combined therapies involving platelet-derived products and other biomaterials or active principles administered simultaneously for the treatment of skin pathologies and conditions were included in the present review.
Table 1 Characteristics of the Included Studies
Figure 2 Study flow diagram.
Most of the selected studies focused on investigating different combinations of platelet derivatives and polymeric biomaterials, such as hyaluronic acid, chitosan, collagen, gelatin, alginate, or cellulose derivatives mainly for treatment of facial ageing, skin injuries, and wounds. Additionally, a small subset of studies evaluated various combinations of platelet derivatives and other bioactive substances and therapeutic agents, including herbal extracts, phenolic compounds, metals, toxins, or antibiotics to treat chronic wounds and hyperpigmentation. After structuring and extracting relevant information, the selected studies were summarized and discussed below:
BiopolymersBiopolymers, as naturally sourced polymers derivatives from living organisms, present significant benefits for wound healing, scarring management, and skin rejuvenation. Their biocompatibility, biodegradability, non-immunogenicity, and versatile structural properties position them as excellent candidates for developing drug delivery systems, advanced biological wound dressings, and scaffolds for tissue regeneration.150 As a consequence, the combination of the bioregenerative potential of PRP with multiple biopolymers or biopolymer-based multifunctional scaffolds has been extensively investigated in aesthetics and medical dermatology:
ChitosanChitosan is a bioactive polymer with numerous applications, driven by its functional properties including antibacterial effects, non-toxicity, ease of modification, biocompatibility, and biodegradability.151 It is the deacetylated form of chitin, a natural copolymer of N-acetylglucosamine and glucosamine residues linked by β-1,4-glycosidic bonds synthesized by fungi, crustacean, squids, and cuttlefish.152 In addition to its excellent mechanical performance, high hydrophilicity and lysozyme degradation properties, chitosan dressings act as strong antimicrobials and procoagulants, enhancing wound healing by creating an optimal environment for cells and beneficial microbiota.153 Higher amount of growth factors can be released into the plasma by incorporating chitosan with high platelet activation ability to PRP,65 thus leading to increased proliferation rates in fibroblasts and adipose tissue-derived stromal cells (ASCs).82 As concluded by Shimojo et al,73 the performance of in association with porous chitosan outperformed PRP alone, as it delayed the release of growth factors and enhanced stem cell proliferation in vitro. Multiple in vivo studies have also revealed that PRP combined with biodegradable chitosan hydrogels showed positive effects on wound healing and could be recommended for treating different types of wounds in both animals and humans.78,97,139 Accordingly, 3D wound healing models revealed that fibroblasts were stimulated, extracellular matrix formation was enhanced and oxidative stress levels decreased in chitosan/gelatin scaffolds loaded with PRP.113 Moreover, PRP loaded shell-core fibrous hydrogels consisting of chitosan, alginate, and gelatin have proven to reduce inflammation and accelerate the growth of granulation tissue and angiogenesis, stimulate the formation of dense hair follicles, and promote the development of a dense and well-organized collagen fiber network.124 Similar pro-healing and pro-hemostatic effects have been observed for hydrogels manufactured with PRP and highly absorbent bio-sponges based on carboxymethyl chitosan/poly-γ-glutamic acid in a murine wound model.128 In the same line, chitosan-gelatin sponges crosslinked with tannic acid and loaded with PRP demonstrated strong antibacterial activity against Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus with low cytotoxicity, and also promoted a rapid healing when applied as wound dressings.77
In vivo experiments developed by Shi et al103 showed that gelatin microspheres (GMs) loading gentamycin sulfate (GS) and PRP and covalently bond to carboxymethyl chitosan (CMC) dressings could accelerate the healing of full-thickness wounds infected with E. coli and S. aureus, promoting re-epithelialization, collagen deposition, and angiogenesis, inhibiting bacterial growth, and modulating the expression of pro-inflammatory cytokines (TNF-α, IL-1β, and IL-6) and anti-inflammatory growth factors (TGF-β1). Other variants, including PRP-loaded hydrogels based on chitosan and PEG have been identified as excellent hemostatic material for superficial wounds with antibacterial and wound healing effects as revealed by in vitro and in vivo experiments,114 whereas CMCS/polyvinyl pyrrolidone (PVP)/Molybdenum (IV) Selenide (MoSe2), and platelet-rich plasma (PRP) (CMCS/PVP/MoSe2/PRP) based antioxidant hydrogels can prevent inflammatory storms by neutralizing free radicals at the wound site and inhibiting the release of inflammatory factors.148 On the other hand, PRP-chitosan/silk fibroin composite dressings could function as effective wound dressings that facilitate rapid hemostasis and accelerates the healing process.98,99 Multifunctional platforms have been also constructed by mixing PRP and alginate-based dressing containing nano silver (Ag)-doped carboxymethyl chitosan grafted polyamide-amine cationic polymers with strong antiinflammatory, antibacterial, and proangiogenic properties.106 In vitro and in vivo experiments conducted by Liu et al144 concluded that a thermosensitive chitosan-based wound dressing hydrogel containing β-glycerophosphate (GP), hydroxy propyl cellulose (HPC), graphene oxide (GO), and PRP for the treatment of skin wounds exhibited antibacterial properties against Pseudomonas aeruginosa and ability to stimulate cell proliferation and migration along with reduced inflammation levels. Finally, according to Bhatnagar et al,100 chitosan (CS) and kenaf nanocrystalline cellulose (NCC) hydrogel composites loaded with platelet lysate (PL) could increase fibroblast proliferation in vitro and enhance wound closure.
Hyaluronic AcidHyaluronic acid (HA) is a natural glycosaminoglycan present in the extracellular matrix of skin, cartilage, bone, and brain, among other tissues. It plays a crucial role in wound healing and tissue repair by creating a humid environment that promotes tissue regeneration, while also modulating the release of growth factors and cellular components and stimulating the movement of different cells that are essential for the healing process.154 During the last decades, several studies have concluded that the combination of PRP and HA may benefit from its synergistic biological effects, supporting the activity of signaling molecules such as inflammatory mediators, catabolic enzymes, cytokines, and growth factors, which could improve the treatment of different skin conditions.72,91,117 In addition to its volumizing and moisturizing effect, it has been concluded that HA sustains platelet stability and induces a prolonged release of growth factors from PRP.155 Moreover, the rheological behavior of HA is especially relevant in the field of dermatology and aesthetic medicine for improving wound healing and skin rejuvenation. In this sense, due to its ability to exhibit both elastic and viscous properties, it is considered as an effective carrier for both topical and transdermal applications, showing high biodegradability and biocompatibility, and low immunogenicity.156
According to Rao et al,117 topical hydrogels manufactured with PRP and HA can accelerate wound healing in mice since they retain their biological activity over extended periods and ensure a continuous release of morphogens to the wound. In line with these findings, both macroscopic and microscopic observations in a rat model revealed that the mean healing period was reduced by 7 days (approximately 33%) in lesions treated with PRP enriched with HA.116 More complex combinations of PRP, HA, and other biopolymers have been also demonstrated remarkable healing properties. For example, Li et al114 developed a self-healing nanocomposite hydrogel (ADAC) based on aldehyde-modified sodium hyaluronate (AHA), hydrazide-modified sodium hyaluronate (ADA), and aldehyde-modified cellulose nanocrystals (oxi-CNC) loaded with PRP with promising mechanical and biological characteristics. As revealed by in vivo models, ADAC hydrogel enhanced full-thickness skin wound repair by stimulating granulation tissue formation, collagen deposition, re-epithelialization, and neovascularization. On the other hand, Wei et al104 constructed a hydrogel by incorporating Schiff base linkages between oxidized dextran (ODEX), antimicrobial peptide-modified hyaluronic acid (HA-AMP), and PRP under physiological conditions. This hydrogel exhibited an initial rapid release of growth factors and antimicrobial peptides (AMP), followed by a sustained long-term release over more than 120 hours. Moreover, in vivo studies revealed that the hydrogel significantly promoted wound healing in diabetic mice with infections by modulating inflammation and enhancing collagen synthesis and angiogenesis. Additionally, the hydrogel displayed notable antibacterial properties against S. aureus and P. aeruginosa, reduced proinflammatory cytokines (TNF-α, IL-1β, and IL-6), and increased the levels of anti-inflammatory factor TGF-β1 and VEGF. Recently, Duan et al136 concluded that injectable adhesive wound dressings (HA-DA/PRP) composed of PRP and dopamine-modified-hyaluronic-acid (HADA) also accelerated in vivo healing of diabetic ulcers by inhibiting bacterial growth, enhancing regenerative and angiogenic processes, promoting collagen deposition, and modulating inflammation through M1→M2 polarization.
Clinical data also support the use of PRP enriched in HA for the treatment of wounds. An observational study involving 364 patients conducted by De Angelis et al91 confirmed the strong regenerative potential of PRP and HA combined in relation to epidermal growth and dermal remodeling. A randomized controlled trial involving 100 participants focused on evaluating the effectiveness of plasma rich in growth factors (PRGF-Endoret®) and HA for the treatment and care of pressure ulcers was published by Ramos-Torrecillas et al.72 As revealed by clinical data, the greatest mean reduction in pressure-ulcer area (80.4% vs baseline) was obtained with the PRGF-Endoret® plus HA regimen. In the same line, Cervelli et al61,63 also concluded that PRP dressings combined with HA are able to stimulate the regeneration of the lower-extremity complex soft- and hard-tissue wounds. As concluded by Gentile et al,75 PRP gel combined with HA resulted in accelerated and uncomplicated effective wound closure, a good cutaneous elasticity and a notable aesthetic improvement in the treatment of complications derived from Achilles tendon reconstruction. A randomized controlled trial published by Roohaninasab et al145 also supported the effectiveness of PRP and non-cross-linked HA injections in patients with burn scars treated with fractional CO2 laser. Similarly, Kartika et al102 observed increased angiogenesis and reduced inflammation in diabetic foot ulcers treated with platelet-rich fibrin and HA after conducting an open-label randomized controlled trial.
In reference to facial rejuvenation, Ulusal et al86 detected a statistically significant improvement in general appearance and also in skin firmness and texture after intradermal applications of platelet-rich plasma combined with HA. These results were confirmed by a randomized controlled prospective study involving 93 patients and published by Hersant et al,101 who concluded that combining platelet-rich plasma and HA could be regarded as a promising treatment for facial rejuvenation, showing highly significant improvements in facial appearance and skin elasticity compared with conventional therapies or PRP alone. Similar approaches have demonstrated to be an efficient therapeutic alternative for patients affected by other skin pathologies. For example, it has been reported that platelet-rich plasma combined with non-cross-linked HA significantly improved hair loss and hair count evaluated at the 3-month follow-up relative to baseline in patients suffering female androgenic alopecia.129 Moreover, Pirrello et al95 concluded that filler injections of HA and PRP constitute an effective strategy to increase skin elasticity, mouth’s opening, and upper lip’s thickness in patients affected by scleroderma.
AlginateAlginate is a naturally sourced biopolymer derived mainly from brown marine algae and certain bacterial taxa that Is widely integrated into biomedical practices due to its desirable physicochemical, mechanical, and biological properties, such as biocompatibility, non-toxicity, affordability, biodegradability, absorbability, and non-immunogenicity.157 It has been widely used to manufacture different variants of wound dressings, including hydrogels, films, wafers, foams, nanofibers, and in topical formulations.158 As revealed by multiple studies, PRP combined with alginate could be considered an effective strategy to accelerate wound healing. In vitro studies on human fibroblasts and keratinocytes demonstrated that a degradable hydrogel composed of alginate and PRP is non-cytotoxic and promotes cell adhesion and proliferation.111 Alginate-based particles are also able to load and release platelet lysate and vancomycin hydrochloride, thus enhancing fibroblast proliferation in the context of chronic skin ulcers.67 According to Wang et al,130 a dual-network hydrogel incorporating sodium alginate (SA) and PRP could stimulate cell proliferation and vascular regeneration and showed a high wound closure effectiveness in rats. Nevertheless, most studies focus on multifunctional hydrogels providing an array of beneficial properties, including antibacterial and antioxidant activities, bioadhesion, and optimized mechanical characteristics. For example, Alinezhad et al120 engineered a calcium-crosslinked PRP-based injectable hydrogel by mixing alginate (Alg), gelatin (GT), polydopamine (PDA), and PRP that exhibited promising photothermal, antibacterial, and antioxidant properties for skin regeneration. A multifunctional hydrogel prepared with PRP, dopamine (DA)-grafted alginate (Alg-DA), and 6-aminobenzo[c][1,2]oxaborol-1(3H)-ol (ABO)-conjugated hyaluronic acid (HA-ABO) through ionic interactions, hydrogen bonds, and boronate ester bonds induce beneficial changes for diabetic wound healing, including rapid anti-inflammatory effects, and also promoted macrophage polarization toward the M2 phenotype, accelerated angiogenesis, increased migration and enhanced proliferation of fibroblasts.131 Similar wound healing promoting results have been obtained using different hydrogels based on platelet-rich plasma and alginate, such as platelet rich plasma-loaded slow-sculpting graphene oxide (GO)/alginate gel134 or PRP-loaded alginate/ carboxymethylcellulose hydrogels.85
Collagens and GelatinCollagens are the most prevalent proteins in the human body. The widespread presence of collagen in animal systems, especially fibrillar collagen type I, is mainly due to its distinct mechanical and physiological properties, such as thermal and chemical stability, mechanical strength, and its ability to interact physiologically.159 During wound healing, fibroblasts and other cells produce these collagens, which are then transformed into complex structures. The collagen superfamily comprises 28 distinct types, which are categorized into eight subfamilies. Most of these collagen types fall under the fibril-forming subfamily, which includes type I, type II, type III, or type V collagen. These two types are the primary components of the extracellular matrix (ECM) in the dermis.160 Collagen plays a critical role in modulating inflammation, angiogenesis, and ECM remodeling, providing valuable support in wound healing therapy. Collagen-based biomaterials are commonly used in wound dressings due to their biocompatibility, low immunogenicity, and ability to attract key wound healing cells such as macrophages and fibroblasts.161 It has been concluded that collagen-induced platelet activation results in sustained release of growth factors and anabolic cytokines.162–164 As demonstrated by do Amaral et al,92 porous collagen-glycosaminoglycan (collagen-GAG) scaffolds functionalized with PRP stimulated the release of key regenerative growth factors for wound healing and vascularization (FGF, TGFβ, VEGF, and PDGF) for up to 14 days, enhanced cell-proliferation and migration in vitro, and also demonstrated increased angiogenic and vascularization potential in vivo. Other collagen-based PRP loaded candidate scaffolds for wound healing and tissue repair include collagen/chondroitin sulfate scaffolds with platelet-rich plasma.142 In the same line, a hydrogel scaffold developed through combination of type I collagen and PRP recruited more stem cells from skin tissue in vivo compared to collagen hydrogels alone at both the 4- and 8-week time points. Additionally, fractionated PRP-enriched hydrogels stimulated wound healing, angiogenesis, and the formation of hair and sweat glands, ultimately leading to the regeneration of dermis-like tissue.76 According to Zheng et al,105 a polydopamine (pDA)-modified collagen sponge scaffold loaded with PRP stimulated in vitro proliferation, adhesion, and migration of keratinocytes and endothelial cells. Moreover, histological results confirmed that wound healing was accelerated in pDA-CSS@PRP scaffolds with less scar formation via rapid angiogenesis and the deposition of more mature and well-organized collagen.
Gelatin is a commonly used natural biopolymer derived from natural collagen with excellent biocompatibility, biodegradability, and non-immunogenicity.165 Additionally, it exhibits other physicochemical characteristics that attained strong interest in the biomedical research such as rheological stability within a pH range of 5 to 9, water solubility, high-viscosity, and temperature sensitivity. As a consequence, gelatin-based biomaterials support wound repair and regeneration due to its adhesive, anti-inflammatory, antibacterial, angiogenic, and regenerative properties.166 As highlighted in multiple studies, platelet-rich plasma combined with gelatin hydrogel granules can promote angiogenenesis in vivo.66,70,71,79,83,94 Clinical trials have also been designed investigate the efficacy and safety profile of PRP covered with a gelatin sheet as dressing for the treatment of chronic wounds.70 Preliminary data suggest that gelatin combined with PRP is a valuable option in the treatment of non-healing wounds.79 Enhanced antimicrobial effects and in vitro HUVEC proliferation promoting properties were observed in methacrylated gelatin hydrogels conjugated with ε-polylysine and enriched with PRP.146 Fiber-reinforced gelatin (GEL)/β-cyclodextrin (β-CD) therapeutic hydrogels loaded with PRP-derived exosomes significantly induced autophagic activity and reduced apoptotic processes in HUVECs and human skin fibroblasts (HSFs), thus stimulating microvascular network creation, collagen synthesis, and re-epithelialization in a diabetic rat wound healing model.127 Accordingly, Gomaa et al138 revealed that PRP integrated into a gelatin (GLT) combined with nanocomposites of titanium dioxide (TiO2) (P25)/single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs)/Ag and P25/reduced graphene oxide (rGO)/Ag showed superior antioxidant activity, enhanced antimicrobial properties, and enhancer tissue repair. Recently, gelatine-based hydrogel (PAH-G) foams loaded with platelet-derived extracellular vesicles (pEVs) demonstrated reduced inflammation in vivo and wound closure after 14 days.149 The in vivo biological effects of combing platelet-rich plasma with synthetic collagen-based skin substitutes59 or acellular human or animal tissues for wound healing and skin repair, including amnion,88 dermis,62,74,93,123,135 fish skin,107 or decellularized extracellular matrix108,126 have also been extensively assessed.
Cellulose DerivativesCellulose is a highly biocompatible, non-toxic, and biodegradable polysaccharide composed of glucose units linked by β-1,4-glycosidic bonds, which is commonly regarded as the most abundant natural biopolymer on Earth.167 Though cellulose is best known as a plant structural molecule, it is also synthesized by various non-plant organisms, including bacteria, oomycetes, algae, slime molds, and the only known cellulose-producing animals: urochordates.168 As a result from its mechanical strength, structural stability exceptional, water absorption capacity, and the capability of cellulose derivatives to create thermally responsive hydrogel systems, it has gained a considerable attention in hydrogel development during the last decades, and different chemical methods, such as oxidation, etherification, and esterification, have been proposed to overcome the poor solubility of cellulose in water and most organic solvents.169 Cellulose derivatives include cellulose dialdehyde (DAC), cellulose dicarboxylic acid (DCC), and 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl-oxidized cellulose nanofibrils (TOCNF), ethylcellulose (EC), methylcellulose (MC), carboxymethylcellulose (CMC), hydroxypropylcellulose (HPC), hydroxypropylmethylcellulose (HPMC), hydroxyethylcellulose (HEC), cellulose acetate (CA), nitrocellulose (CN), cellulose sulfate (CS), cellulose acetobutyrate (CAB), and hydroxypropylmethylcellulose phthalate (HPMCP). Cellulose-based biomaterials have been utilized in wound healing or tissue engineering applications to mimic skin, accelerate the regeneration of skin cells, and reduce scarring.170
Both in vitro and in vivo models confirmed that carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) scaffolds loaded with PRP sustained the release of growth factors, stimulated angiogenesis, stem cell migration, and facilitated re-epithelialization, granulation, and angiogenesis in full-thickness skin defects of diabetic wounds.109 A pilot study that investigated the clinical performance of a hydrogel consisting of umbilical cord blood platelet gel (CBPG) and CMC revealed that this dressing demonstrated efficacy in promoting faster regeneration of chronic wounds with no observed adverse effects.110 Cellulose derivatives are commonly included into multifunctional formulations.100,143 As published by Cai et al,122 a composite adhesive organohydrogel manufactured via introduction of bacterial cellulose and PRP into a poly-N-(tris[hydroxymethyl]methyl)acrylamide (THMA)/N-acryloyl aspartic acid (AASP) hybrid organohydrogel stimulated angiogenesis and collagen deposition in vivo, thus accelerating the wound healing process. A randomized controlled trial published by Kakagia et al60 reported that a significant three-dimensional reduction of diabetic foot ulcers was achieved in individuals treated with a combination of oxidized regenerated cellulose/collagen biomaterial and PRP compared to both cellulose/collagen or PRP alone.
Other BiopolymersThe mechanical and biological performance of PRP combined with a wide range of biopolymers has been explored. Yang et al64 observed enhanced angiogenesis and epidermal regeneration in vivo after treating wounds with PRP and heparin-conjugated fibrin (HCF). Platelet-rich formulations have also been combined to treat refractory wounds, with significant reductions in wound area and duration.171 Cocoon composites derived from the silkworm Bombyx mori have demonstrated improved water absorption and retention capacities. After loading with PRP, these composites stimulated cell growth in vitro and enhanced the wound healing process in a rabbit wound healing model.84 The combination of platelet-rich plasma-based gels with silk fibroin gel have proven to augment both the compressive stiffness and rheological properties of PRP-based gels, and promoted cell infiltration and blood vessel neoformation when injected in nude rats.68 Similar results were obtained by Pignatelli et al89 after combining silk fibroin fibers with platelet lysate (PL). As revealed by in vitro and in vivo experiments, PRP-loaded dual-crosslinked silk protein-based hydrogel systems (SP) (sericin and fibroin) stimulated diabetic wound healing more effectively than platelet-rich plasma and SP by increasing the expression of growth factors, inhibiting matrix metalloproteinase-9 (MMP-9) expression, and promoting anti-NETotic activity, angiogenesis, and re-epithelialization.121 On the other hand, the application of combined treatment consisting of Curcuma zedoaria polysaccharides with PRP-derived exosomes assembled on chitosan/silk hydrogel sponge in wounded diabetic rats resulted in a significant reduction of ulcer size and an increase of epidermal thickness.90 Zhao and Yuan et al147 proposed a multifunctional hydrogel backbone composed of pullulan polysaccharide derivatives (OPD), polylysine derivatives (EPL-BA) with encapsulated tea polyphenols (TP), gallic acid (GA), and metal ions (Cu2+) loaded with PRP with antibacterial, anti-inflammatory, regenerative, and pro-angiogenic properties to treat infected wounds. Regenerative properties have also been described for lactic acid and glycolic acid-based hydrogels loaded with PRP.69,80,140
Plant-Derived ExtractsTo date, the incorporation of plant products as additives or adjuvants in platelet derivatives has been little explored. In this sense, the deleterious effect of many plant secondary metabolites on platelet functionality could be considered as a significant limitation to the development of mixed formulations, since they could lead to impaired clot formation and altered release of growth factors. For example, several studies have concluded that the phenolic fraction derived from olive oil effectively reduces platelet aggregation and eicosanoid formation in vitro.172–174 Similarly, sea buckthorn berry oil, Vitis vinifera or Arachis hypogaea seed oils have also demonstrated to suppress or reduce platelet function.175,176 In the same line, the inhibition of platelet aggregation by plant aqueous or ethanolic extracts has been widely described.177–181 Nevertheless, the treatment of skin diseases in humans has long benefited from plants, which offer a wide array of bioactive molecules with therapeutic properties.182 In a novel study, Rastegar et al58 concluded that the combination of herbal extracts derived from the fruits of Persea americana, flowers of Althaea officinalis, Chamaemelum nobile, Thymus vulgaris, and leaves of Rosmarinus officinalis, Urtica dioica and PRP was shown to significantly promote the proliferation of human dermal papilla cells (DPCs) through G1 cell cycle progression at concentrations between 1.5% and 4.5%. This study demonstrated that ERK phosphorylation and phosphorylated Akt expression increased dose-dependently following treatment with herbal extracts in the presence of PRP. In this sense and despite the field remains largely unexplored, the authors consider that the incorporation of phytochemicals as bioactive molecules in platelet derivative-based formulations constitutes a promising direction for future regenerative dermatological applications. As highlighted by Zhou et al,183 a wide range of plant-based bioactive molecules, such as polyphenols, terpenes, alkaloids, and carotenoids, are easily obtained, inexpensive, mostly safe, and reliable, and have also demonstrated multiple biological properties including anti-inflammatory, antibacterial, antioxidant activity, proangiogenic behavior, and ability to promote stem cell differentiation.
Other AdjuvantsA combination of PRP and botulinum toxin A has been explored for the treatment of hyaluronic acid embolic cutaneous necrosis and alopecia that has yielded positive and encouraging outcomes.112 In reference to therapeutic drugs, a combination therapy based on platelet-rich plasma and hydroquinone exhibited a higher effectiveness than hydroquinone alone in treatment of melasma.119 Regarding inorganic molecules, Lin et al125 concluded that platelet-rich fibrin (PRF) with nano silver (AgNP) dressing effectively reduces pain and local inflammation in patients with chronic refractory wounds, enhances the wound healing rate, accelerates recovery time, and reduces the risk of complications. In vivo experiments have also demonstrated that platelet-rich plasma combined with zinc oxide ointments applied subcutaneously could be effective in accelerating wound healing.87 In the same line, Karas et al141 recently demonstrated that the synergistic interaction between selenium nanoparticles (SeNPs) and PRP significantly improved wound repair in diabetic murine models, with selenium’s antibacterial characteristics playing a pivotal role. An injectable bioactive dressing based on PRP and the nano-clay laponite (DPLG) has shown to accelerate wound healing through promotion of macrophage polarization and angiogenesis in a full-thickness skin defect model in both type I diabetic and normal rats.133 According to Carney et al,96 inorganic polyphosphate in PRP can also stimulate re-epithelization process in vivo and in vitro. The regenerative properties of PRP have been also combined with antibiotics to treat infected wounds. For example, Yang et al132 evaluated the antimicrobial and wound healing potential the combination or PRP with β-lactams (ampicillin and/or oxacillin) for the administration on methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA)-infected skin. The results of this study concluded that the combination of platelet-rich plasma and β-lactam antibiotics demonstrated a synergistic effect, reducing wound area by 39%, as PRP enhanced keratinocyte proliferation and suppressed macrophage infiltration at the wound site, leading to a shorter inflammatory phase and an accelerated activation of the proliferative phase.
In spite of the heterogeneity observed across the included studies regarding experimental designs, combination therapies, and pathological conditions, no significant adverse events associated with combined therapies of platelet derivatives and biomaterials, active agents, or adjuvants were reported. The autologous origin of platelet derivatives inherently minimizes immunogenicity, with any observed reactions generally confined to mild, local, and transient responses associated with the injection procedure. Provided that standardized preparation and administration procedures are implemented, these therapies can be considered to have a low overall risk, excluding potential contributions from co-delivered biomaterials, active molecules, or adjuvants. Future in vivo and clinical studies should focus on the systematic evaluation of potential side effects, assessing both individual biomaterial, active agents, or adjuvants and their combined formulations. In this sense, transparent and standardized reporting of such events will be essential to strengthen the evidence base, inform safer and more effective clinical application, and ultimately improve patient-centered outcomes.
Decision Making ProcessPRP, PRGF-Endoret,® and other platelet-rich formulations have been shown to be effective in treating several dermatological conditions including hair loss, dermatological disorders (lichen planus and melasma, among others), wound healing, scar revision, vitiligo, facial rejuvenation, and aesthetics.184–190 The development of a wide arrange of therapeutic formulations (Figure 1) have allowed platelet-rich derivatives such as PRGF-Endoret® to be used as a stand-alone therapy in most of these applications. Through the modulation of the immune response and tissue formation, these hemoderivatives can affect the clinical progress of the postoperative recovery by achieving less pain, less inflammation, better quality of life, and accelerated tissue formation.191,192 Their clinical use should be based on the understanding of the physiology of tissue healing, through the phases of hemostasis, inflammation, proliferation and remodeling, and the clinical condition to treat.193 This understanding will determine the specific objectives to achieve through the implementation of a combined regenerative approach that requires the design and execution of a strategic plan to assess its effectiveness.
Different approaches are being developed within regenerative dermatology to target delivery of bioactive molecules to localized wounds, enhancing repair and accelerating regeneration.194 Basic and clinical research should complement each other within the framework of providing evidence-driven translation from laboratory research to clinical application, confirming safety and performance. Moreover, such a combined strategy should be tailored to clinical procedures and be cost-effective. As highlighted in the review, the integration of growth factors and appropriate biomaterials, via physical or chemical interactions, facilitates sustained local delivery at effective doses, thereby improving tissue regeneration and the performance of biopolymers in skin repair.191,192
Commonly used biopolymers include hyaluronic acid, chitosan, collagen, gelatin, alginate, and cellulose derivatives. The selection of PRP as source of growth factors is justified by the fact that the healing process is orchestrated by multiple growth factors and cytokines that induce adequate cellular response and cell–cell communication during its progress.43,195 Additionally, the gluing properties of fibrin (the product of activating the coagulation cascade in PRP) would improve the handling and delivery of the biomaterials.196 The core of the PRP is the enrichment with platelets and the preparation protocols are designed for that purpose.197,198 In addition, platelets play a dual role in hemostasis and immunomodulation to facilitate healing. They are reservoirs for many growth factors, proteins, and cytokines that mediate tissue healing after an injury. To have them available it is very important to activate the platelet to induce cytoplasmic changes and the attachment of granules to the plasma membrane and subsequent degranulation. This occurs concurrently with the conversion of fibrinogen to fibrin giving rise to 3D-structure.199 The fibrin matrix is transformed into a collagen-rich extracellular matrix that eventually matures into functional tissue. However, their mechanical stability is determined by the relatively fast degradation of fibrin and thus they will need support for the treatment of critical-size defects or when there is a demand on better mechanical properties like the case of correcting tissue defects200,201 In these cases, combination with other biomaterials would leverage their use in the clinical setting.
Thus, it is important to assess the effect of PRP on the physical and chemical properties of the biopolymer as well as the effect of that biopolymer on the platelet activation and the formation of the fibrin.191,192 Furthermore, tailoring the incorporation method is essential to produce scaffolds aligned with specific clinical requirements. For example, distribution of the PRP within the biomaterial and the susceptibility to degradation, erosion, or swelling would be expected to condition the biological performance. Moreover, the type of PRP should be selected in the quest of achieving optimized biomaterial performance.193 This aspect has received little attention in the reviewed literature. There are a wide variety of protocols to obtain PRP that yields different products in terms of cellular composition and the final volume of PRP26,27,31 Accordingly, differences in platelet and leukocyte content lead to variability in the biological outcomes derived from platelet-rich plasma administration. When selecting a specific type of PRP, it would be helpful to critically assess the available basic and clinical evidence of the performance of that product in regenerative dermatology. The availability of standardized protocols of the selected PRP products would also ensure the comparability of the different studies assessing that specific formulation.
From a regulatory perspective, PRP is a medicinal product and its combination with biopolymers has an important impact on the route to achieve marketing authorization of the combined product. In the scenario where he combined product is released as an independent product, the combination may be subject to oversight from two distinct regulatory environments. If the use of PRP is ancillary to the medical device (biopolymers), then it will be, according to the Article 1 first and second paragraph of the medical device regulation (MDR) an integral product which is a medical device incorporates one or more substances which, if used separately, would be considered a medicinal product, including medicinal products derived from human blood or plasma, non-viable tissues, or cells of human origin or their derivatives as an integral part, within the meaning of 1 MDR, if and only if, the device and the substance form an integral product, when placed on the market or put into service. Under this scenario, the combined device will be under the scope of the MDR (Medical Device Coordination Group).202 However, if the action of the PRP is principal, then it will be governed by the Directive 2001/83/EC203 or by Regulation (EC) No 726/2004,204 but the relevant general safety and performance requirements of Annex I to the MDR shall apply as far as the safety and performance-related device features are concerned.
However, if the biopolymer use is intended to administer the PRP at the injured site, then the combined product will be a single integral product which is a device intended to administer a medicinal product and the respective medicinal product form a single integral product, within the meaning of Article 1 of MDR,202 if and only if the device and the medicinal product form an integral entity when placed on the market and, furthermore, the product is intended exclusively for use in the given combination and which is not reusable.
Thus, a single integral product consists of at least two constituent parts, one of which is a device and the other a medicinal product, which are combined in such a manner that they are not intended to be separated prior to administration.
Within this framework, the integral product is governed by the Directive 2001/83/EC203 or by Regulation (EC) No 726/2004.204 However, the relevant general safety and performance requirements outlined in Annex I of the MDR shall apply with respect to the device’s safety and performance-related features. Another possibility that reflects the clinical reality is that the two products are authorized independently and their combination (the PRP and the biopolymer) is performed by the clinicians according to the clinical evaluation of the patient needs. Therefore, a systematic approach needs to be
Comments (0)